It’s SoCon baseball tourney time, live from Riley Park in beautiful downtown Charl…
Oh. They moved the tournament this year.
That’s right. After 19 consecutive years in Charleston, the powers that be in the Southern Conference wilted from the non-stop complaints of a select few and moved the tournament (for at least one year) to Greenville, where it will be held at Fluor Field. (The tourney returns to Riley Park next year.)
The tournament regularly made money (!) when it was held in Charleston. Don’t expect it to do so in Greenville, where it will lack the kind of community support that has made it successful in the Holy City. Of course, the conference doesn’t realy need the money. Wait, what’s that you say? The economic climate in the country has hit the SoCon hard? The league is cutting costs, including not holding media days for football and basketball? It’s going to reduce the number of teams that qualify for conference tournaments in sports like women’s soccer, men’s soccer, women’s tennis, men’s tennis, volleyball, and softball? It’s going to force conference baseball series next year to be held over two days rather than three, with Saturday doubleheaders, to save on travel expenses? It’s going to do all those things and then cut off its nose to spite its face by moving its baseball tourney just to please a small group of whiners?
Yes, it is. (The league is also not printing media guides next year, although that strikes me as a good permanent move, what with being able to publish the guides online. It would be nice if the conference updated its historical records information in hoops and baseball, which hasn’t been done in several years.)
The complaints came over a perceived home field advantage for The Citadel (and for the College of Charleston to a lesser extent). The loudest of the voices was that of UNC Greensboro coach Mike Gaski, who campaigned to move the tournament for about a decade, or not too long after his 1998 squad had been defeated by The Citadel in the tournament championship game. That was UNCG’s first year in the league after having lots of success in the Big South. Gaski’s crew had won the regular season in the SoCon by a half-game over The Citadel, and by one game over Western Carolina, in a very tight three-way race. Then the tournament rolled around. The Spartans had actually swept the Bulldogs in Charleston earlier that season, but when the games really mattered, The Citadel prevailed twice over UNCG by a combined score of 21-1.
There really should not have been much to complain about — 21-1 strikes me as being rather decisive — but that was just the start of the drumbeat for moving the tourney. The thing is, though, UNCG hasn’t won the league regular season title since then. The Spartans did make it to the tourney title game in 2001, as the 5 seed, when they lost to (of course) The Citadel, which probably rankled Gaski even more.
As everyone knows, home field advantage in baseball isn’t nearly as important as it is in football or basketball. There is no comparison between The Citadel playing tournament games at Riley Park and UT-Chattanooga getting to host the SoCon men’s hoops tourney on its home court. That is borne out by the numbers. While UTC has won the basketball tournament both times it has hosted it, I think some people would be surprised if they took a look at the baseball tournament history since the SoCon set up shop in Charleston. There have been 19 tournaments held in Chucktown, and here is the breakdown over that time span:
The Citadel — 5 regular season titles, 7 tournament titles
College of Charleston — 3 regular season titles, 1 tournament title
Western Carolina — 3 regular season titles, 4 tournament titles
Georgia Southern — 5 regular season titles, 3 tournament titles
Elon — 2 regular season titles, 1 tournament title
UNC Greensboro — 1 regular season title, 0 tournament titles
Furman — 0 regular season titles, 2 tournament titles
Wofford — 0 regular season titles, 1 tournament title
The Citadel is +2 overall in 19 years of hosting the event (in terms of tourney versus regular season titles). Meanwhile, the other local school reputed to have at least something of an edge by the tournament being held in Charleston, the CofC, is -2. So much for a huge local advantage.
After Gaski and UNCG, the school with the most fans critical of the tournament being held in Charleston is probably Western Carolina — but the Catamounts have had their fair share of success there, and are +1. Really, it’s Georgia Southern that logically would have the biggest complaint (-2), but its fans don’t seem to have had nearly as much of an issue with the tournament being held in the port city (it’s not an inconvenient location for them, for one thing).
The school that appears to have had the biggest benefit to playing in Charleston, as far as tourney vs. regular season success goes, is Furman, with no league regular season titles but two tourney titles since 1990. Thus, the conference in its infinite wisdom is moving the tournament so the Paladins can be the host team…
You know what this is really about? It’s about programs not being as successful as they once were, and not getting in the NCAA tournament, and looking for an excuse. Western Carolina dominated the league in the mid-to-late 1980s, winning five straight tournament titles from 1985-89, all of which were held either in Cullowhee, Boone, or Asheville. In those five years, WCU also happened to win the league regular season (or division) title four times. The Catamounts also won a division title in 1984, but didn’t win the tournament that season.
UNC Greensboro won the Big South in 1994 and 1997, winning that conference’s tournament title both years as well. It entered the Southern Conference following the ’97 campaign.
Western Carolina fans remember the glory days of winning the league every year. The Catamounts have generally still been competitive, and among the better teams in the league, but they don’t win the conference title every year, and that is reflected in WCU’s tournament results. The same can be said for UNCG, which has usually been good, but hasn’t enjoyed as much success as it had in the Big South immediately prior to joining the SoCon.
Unfortunately for Gaski and the Spartans, the year the tournament finally moves to Greenville has coincided with that of one of his worst squads, and UNCG has not qualified for this year’s tournament. I suspect the coach finds that particularly galling.
I hope that Greenville does a decent job hosting the event. I think it’s safe to assume that there will be a tarp at Fluor Field. As some of us remember, that wasn’t the case when the tournament was held in Asheville. The league can’t afford to repeat the 1989 debacle, which just screamed “Mickey Mouse conference” (and which led directly to the tournament moving to Charleston).
I suppose any of the eight teams in the tournament could win it, but I would rank them like this:
Elon — clearly the best team in the league; NCAA lock
Georgia Southern, The Citadel, Western Carolina, College of Charleston — all think they can win the tourney
Appalachian State, Davidson — dangerous, but probably not dangerous enough to win the tournament
Furman — happy to be the host
The latest projections from Baseball America, SEBaseball.com, etc., suggest that as many as three teams from the SoCon can make the NCAAs. I am a little dubious about that. Elon is definitely in, but if the Phoenix win the league tournament I don’t know what other team, if any, will join them as a regional participant. That will depend on how the other teams fare in Greenville. My best guess is that Georgia Southern is best positioned to get a bid from among the other schools. I think The Citadel and the College of Charleston have to win the tournament (that’s probably a given for the CofC at this point), and that Western Carolina may have to at least reach the championship game.
The seedings were thus very important for the contenders, and the short straw was drawn by WCU and the CofC. Not only do those two squads have to play each other in the first round, but the winner likely has to face Elon in the next game. Georgia Southern’s second-place league finish means that the Eagles avoid all three of those teams until at least Friday (the same is true for The Citadel). That said, this tournament has a history of early-round upsets, and neither Appalachian State nor Davidson are easy outs. Even Furman has to be given a puncher’s chance.
As for The Citadel, I would like the Bulldogs’ chances a lot more if the relief pitching were a little better. Drew Mahaffey is a quality closer, but the setup corps has left a lot to be desired. Fred Jordan only appears to have faith in one other reliever, Raymond Copenhaver, but Copenhaver has had his ups and downs this year.
Of course, one solution to the problem with the relief pitching is to have the starters all throw complete games, similar to what happened in 2004 (when The Citadel had a tournament-record five complete games, two by Jonathan Ellis). If a particular starter is effective, then Jordan is likely to leave him in the game as long as he possibly can.
The Bulldogs appear to be playing better defensively, and the offense is close to its peak level entering the tournament, which is good. If the bottom of the order can be at least somewhat productive, The Citadel should score a lot of runs, because batters 1-6 have been getting the job done.
I favor Elon to win the tournament, but I am hoping the Bulldogs can have a special week. I would also find it a bit amusing if The Citadel wins the tournament in a year when it’s not held in Charleston.
Filed under: Baseball, The Citadel | Tagged: Appalachian State, Baseball America, Big South, College of Charleston, Davidson, Drew Mahaffey, Elon, Fluor Field, Fred Jordan, Furman, Georgia Southern, Jonathan Ellis, Mike Gaski, Raymond Copenhaver, Riley Park, SEBaseball.com, Southern Conference, The Citadel, UNC-Greensboro, Western Carolina, Wofford |