A quick review of The Citadel’s home opener

The advanced stats from South Carolina State-The Citadel:

  South Carolina State The Citadel
Starting Field Position Average 24.38 29.33
Success Rate 54.4% 29.2%
Big plays (20+ yards) 3 4
Finishing drives inside 40 (average points) 4.6 5.0
Turnovers 0 1
Expected turnovers 0.00 0.44
Possessions 8 9
Points per possession 2.88 2.22
Offensive Plays 68 48
Offensive rush play % 61.76% 50.00%
Yards/rush (sack-adjusted) 5.14 4.79
Yards/pass attempt (sack-adjusted) 6.58 6.67
Yards/play 5.94 5.72
3rd down conversions 58.3% (7-12) 25.0% (3-12)
4th down conversions 0 of 0 2 of 3
Red Zone TD% 60.0% 66.7%
Net punting 37.67 43.33
Time of possession 36:13 26:47
TOP/offensive play 30.61 seconds 29.73 seconds
Penalties 9 for 55 yards 6 for 50 yards
1st down passing 4/8 (55 yards) 4/6 (88 yards)
3rd and long passing 3/4, one sack (33 net yards) 7/9, one sack (56 net yards)
4th down passing 0/0 1/2 (9 yards)
1st down yards/play 6.81 6.94
3rd down average yards to go 5.75 8.12
Defensive 3-and-outs+ 3 (of 9) 1 (of 8)

Housekeeping regarding the above stats:

  • These statistics do not include South Carolina State’s last two drives of each half (three plays in all). The second-half omission is obvious (one play, a kneel-down). I also elected not to include the two plays SCSU ran following the interception late in the first half, because only 12 seconds remained and South Carolina State was in what you could call “desperation mode” in terms of trying to score points (and thus the two-play sequence was not part of the regular course of action). As far as that statistical decision is concerned, your mileage may vary.
  • That means one of South Carolina State’s ‘big plays’ (those of 20 yards or more) is not included in the totals, either (a 21-yard pass reception to end the first half).
  • There was an error in the statistical play-by-play for the game which affected several categories. The problem arose during SCSU’s first drive of the second half. I think I’ve corrected everything in terms of the stats breakdown. (Among other things, this explains a discrepancy involving South Carolina State’s third-down and fourth-down conversion numbers.)
  • Stats-can-be-deceiving dept.: you might notice The Citadel averaged a quite respectable 6.94 yards on first down. Keep in mind that two long pass plays in the second half greatly affected that statistic. In the first half, on the other hand, The Citadel averaged 1.71 yards per play on first down.

Random observations about the game and the atmosphere surrounding it:

– I was a little surprised at the attendance. I thought there would be more fans on hand (from both sides, to be honest). While the listed attendance of 10,579 was notable, I wasn’t completely sure that reflected the actual number of people at the game.

I have my doubts that noon kickoffs are the way to go at The Citadel in the long term, but I suppose this year is a bit of a trial run.

– The Marching 101 is a great band, and I enjoyed its halftime performance. I have to wonder, though, at the band’s repeated playing at the start of (and during) plays. I was half-expecting the referee to give a warning, but that never happened.

The really unfortunate thing that occurred was the Marching 101 playing throughout the special tribute to Willie Jeffries in the break between the first and second quarters. I suspect officials from both schools were not particularly happy about that.

– I will add that I thought the folks running the sound system also veered very close to the edge when it came to musical cues and the start of on-field action.

– It was nice to see Jan Taaffe honored as well as Jeffries. I think Maurice Drayton’s commitment to acknowledging the past history of The Citadel’s football program (and that of the Palmetto State in general) is refreshing.

– I also liked that this year, the Hall of Fame honorees were presented to the crowd at halftime so that they faced the West stands, instead of facing the scoreboard (which, if memory serves, had been the case in previous years). Now everyone just needs to make sure all the honorees are in alphabetical order when the announcements start being made.

– Dumb question alert: where was the U.S. flag?

[Edit: I have now been informed (thanks!) that the flagpole has an internal issue with the pulley system that is preventing the flag from being locked in the ‘up’ position or lowered. Repairs are expected soon. For Saturday’s game, the color guard was used to present colors.]

– I would have preferred white pants to go with The Citadel’s light blue jerseys. The light blue pants didn’t look bad, though.

– Perhaps this has been the case before and I just didn’t notice, but the ‘red hat guy’ for the game was a member of the Corps of Cadets. He industriously trotted out with the media timeout countdown clock for every stoppage of play.

– I think all of the free t-shirts were size extra-large. They were free, though.

– I’m glad the rain mostly held off, though it led to occasionally steamy conditions with the cloud cover and temperature.

– Johnathan Bennett only threw one first-down pass in the first half (the interception at the end of it). In the second half, he was 4 for 5 passing on first down for 88 yards, including two big plays. The offensive playcalling arguably needs to be more varied at the start of games.

– The Citadel kicked off from midfield after its last touchdown, following a 15-yard penalty on South Carolina State. I was hoping that Maurice Drayton might try an onside kick in that situation, because the team really doesn’t lose too much in the way of field position even if unsuccessful — and if does recover the kick, it gets a free possession in great field position.

– The fourth-down run for 33 yards on what I’ll call the “bunch” formation was a great call, and very well executed. It was set up by a similar formation on a fourth down play earlier in the game, one that resulted in SCSU jumping offsides.

– The Citadel had false start penalties at the start of both of its first two drives. That should not happen.

– South Carolina State was a well-coached team. Deondra Duehart is a quality running back, and I thought Eric Phoenix did a nice job running the show. He was also a better runner than his prior stats had indicated. SCSU’s line play on offense and defense was generally solid.

I’m guessing that improving its offensive red zone production will be a point of emphasis for SCSU once conference play rolls around.

– For the second week in a row, the Bulldogs had the edge in special teams play. This time, it wasn’t quite enough to pull out a victory.

There is something to be said about having a chance to win a game despite losing the turnover battle (1-0) and having the opponent run a higher percentage of successful plays from scrimmage by almost a 2-1 margin. Going forward, though, The Citadel has to get better on both sides of the ball. The offense has to be more dynamic throughout the game, and the defense needs to be considerably more disruptive.

This recent spate of blogging by yours truly will now come to a crashing halt. I won’t be around much (or at all) until the end of September/beginning of October.

Next week’s game is against a North Greenville squad that lost its home opener last Thursday night by the exact same score as The Citadel (23-20). NGU’s loss came in overtime to the defending NAIA champions, so the Trailblazers are likely a good-to-very good D2 squad. The Bulldogs better be ready for that one.

The Citadel then opens conference play at Mercer, a playoff team last season which is currently 2-0, winning those two games by a combined score of 94-12. The following week will be a Parents’ Day affair against East Tennessee State, a completely revamped squad that won on Saturday by a score of 61-0.

In other words, more challenges are ahead.

Go Dogs!

2024 Football: The Citadel’s home opener

South Carolina State at The Citadel, to be played at historic Johnson Hagood Stadium (minus the yet-to-be-rebuilt East stands) in Charleston, South Carolina, with kickoff at 12:00 pm ET on September 7, 2024.

The game will be streamed on ESPN+. Dave Weinstein will handle play-by-play duties, with former James Madison quarterback Vad Lee providing the analysis. The sideline reporter will be Ainsley Clifford.

The contest can be heard on radio via The Citadel Sports Network. WQNT-1450 AM [audio link], originating in Charleston, will be the flagship station.

Brian Giffin calls the action alongside analyst Lee Glaze.

Just a few links:

I’m just tossing out a few things here. As I mentioned when I posted after the Bulldogs’ win on Saturday, I’m semi-retired from blogging, and if you’re going to do something, you need to do it right, and not just go halfway.

That’s why I am ambivalent about posting. I simply don’t have the time to do it justice.

Anyway, let’s get started with this preview, which will primarily be focused on The Citadel’s opponent this Saturday — South Carolina State.

Here is the advanced stats box for South Carolina State’s 22-18 loss at Florida A&M on Saturday:

South Carolina State Florida A&M
Starting Field Position Average 23.5 29.3
Offensive Success Rate 44.3% 46.5%
Big plays (20+ yards) 3 4
Finishing drives inside 40 (average points) 5.0 4.4
Turnovers 0 2
Expected turnovers 1.1 2.1
Possessions 10 10
Points per possession 1.8 2.2
Offensive plays 61 69
Offensive rush play % 54.10% 43.48%
Yards/rush (sack-adjusted) 5.24 4.63
Yards/pass attempt (sack-adjusted) 4.04 7.18
Yards/play 4.69 6.07
3rd down conversions 30.0% (3-10) 64.3% (9-14)
4th down conversions 0 for 0 1 for 1
Red Zone TD% 66.7% 50.0%
Net punting 40.5 41.33
Time of possession 27:21 31:31
TOP/offensive play 26.90 seconds 26.32 seconds
Penalties 10 for 65 yards 6 for 65 yards
1st down passing 3/7 (9 yards) 10/18 (113 yards)
3rd and long passing 1/3, one sack (-3 net yards) 6/8, one sack (91 net yards)
4th down passing 0/0 0/0
1st down yards/play 4.43 5.90
3rd down average yards to go 6.5 7.5
Defensive 3-and-outs+ 2 (of 10) 5 (of 10)

A few housekeeping notes on the above:

  • The statistics do not include the final three offensive plays by Florida A&M, which were kneel-downs.
  • The end of the first half featured a hurry-up drive by South Carolina State which resulted in a field goal. SCSU made it to the red zone just before the half ended, but didn’t have time to run a full set of plays inside the 20 (kicking on 3rd down), and thus that drive is not included in the ‘Red Zone TD%’ or ‘Finishing drives inside 40’ categories.
  • Both teams benefited from a defensive penalty on a 3rd-and-long play, leading to an automatic first down. Those plays aren’t reflected in the ‘3rd down conversions’ or ‘3rd and long passing’ categories.

As far as the quality of South Carolina State’s opponent last week is concerned, Florida A&M was ranked in the preseason FCS coaches’ poll (25th) and is considered one of the contenders to win the SWAC (2nd in the East division in that league’s preseason poll). Of course, last season FAMU was 12-1 and won both the SWAC and the Celebration Bowl.

Random comment: I’m still not used to Florida A&M being a member of the SWAC and not the MEAC. 

I should also note that the game was the Rattlers’ second of the 2024 campaign, while it was the debut for S.C. State and its new coach, Chennis Berry.

South Carolina State held an 18-7 lead early in the 4th quarter, but the Rattlers then scored two touchdowns down the stretch to pull off the comeback.

S.C. State will rue only getting 3 points out of a 1st-and-goal from the 1-yard line situation in the first quarter, and later having a PAT blocked (which led to an unsuccessful 2-point try after another TD). Florida A&M also converted multiple 3rd-and-long plays down the stretch, which had to be frustrating for the garnet-and-blue faithful.

The Bulldogs from Orangeburg were also bedeviled by several untimely penalties, including multiple procedural infractions. That is not overly unusual for a team playing its first game for a new coach.

According to the online participation report, only 40 players took the field for S.C. State. That apparent lack of depth could have been a factor in SCSU’s inability to stop Florida A&M in the 4th quarter. (As always, participation reports should not necessarily be taken at face value.)

It was a little odd that the more rush-focused team (South Carolina State) came out on the short end of the time of possession battle by more than four minutes. Part of the late-game push by FAMU included holding the ball for 9:38 of the final period.

Per the Massey Ratings, Florida A&M is ranked 52nd in FCS; The Citadel is 72nd; South Carolina State is 92nd; and Charleston Southern is 106th.

The Citadel jumped 29 spots after its win last week, but SC State is still favored in the matchup, according to Massey, with a projected score of 26-24. In fact, Massey still rates The Citadel an underdog in all of its remaining 2024 contests save one (next week’s game against North Greenville).

Bill Connelly’s SP+ ratings have Florida A&M ranked 53rd in FCS, with South Carolina State 78th, Charleston Southern 81st, and The Citadel 111th (only a 3-spot rise from last week). His projected score for the game at Johnson Hagood Stadium is S.C. State 26.3, The Citadel 20.6.

(Incidentally, the SP+ projected score for the Charleston Southern-Furman game is Paladins 33.4, Buccaneers 9.1.)

South Carolina State’s starting quarterback (Eric Phoenix) is left-handed, and its placekicker (Kyle Gallegos) is left-footed. There cannot be many teams around that have a left-handed QB *and* a left-footed kicker.

Alas, punter Dyson Roberts is right-footed. You can’t have it all.

No one on South Carolina State’s roster is a graduate of Orangeburg-Wilkinson High School. That might be unprecedented. It is certainly unwise. In my unbiased opinion, failing to have a representative of the famed maroon and orange is a recipe for disaster.

Buddy Pough’s final team at South Carolina State included just seven transfers from junior colleges and/or four-year institutions. Chennis Berry’s current roster at SCSU has 37 such players, including 14 who played for him at Benedict.

Only 19 players who saw action against The Citadel last season (a 31-10 victory for South Carolina State) participated in SCSU’s matchup with Florida A&M. However, eleven of them started against FAMU, including four members of the offensive line and the three players (Justin Smith-Brown, Tyler Smith, and Keshawn Toney) who accounted for all four touchdowns against The Citadel.

Linebackers Zan Dunham and Aaron Smith are also returning starters; Dunham led SCSU in tackles in last year’s matchup, while Smith had two tackles for loss. Defensive back Jamare Bejamin, who intercepted a pass during the game, is back as well.

Berry has supplemented that group with several interesting players, including 6’4″, 340 lb. guard Roger Smith, wide receiver Caden High (3 receptions against Florida A&M, a 39-yarder among them), running back Deondra Duehart (74 yards on 10 rushes versus FAMU), defensive linemen Josh Barker and Jayden Broughton (who had a sack and fumble recovery against the Rattlers), linebacker Dedrick Starkes, and defensive back Diego Addison (six tackles in Tallahassee).

All of those players are transfers from Benedict; Smith and Broughton were first-team all-conference selections in the SIAC last year, while Duehart and Starkes were second-team picks. They were key cogs in a Tigers squad that went undefeated in the regular season for the second year in a row.

Without them (and Berry), Benedict lost 23-7 last week to Virginia State in its season opener.

As mentioned earlier, S.C. State’s starting quarterback is Eric Phoenix, a 6’3″, 210 lb. native of Savannah who is not going to be arm-tackled by anybody. Phoenix played for Chennis Berry at Benedict for three years, including the 2022 campaign, but spent last season at Murray State. This year, he is back with Berry, but at a new school.

In Phoenix’s career at Benedict, he appeared in 28 games at QB, completing 63.5% of his passes (8.1 yards/attempt), with 32 touchdowns against 18 interceptions. He did not run a lot, though he did compile eight rushing TDs for the Tigers. Phoenix was voted second-team All-SIAC after both the 2021 and 2022 seasons.

Against Florida A&M on Saturday, he was 12 for 25 passing for 132 yards and a touchdown. He was sacked twice and had six other rushing attempts.

Chennis Berry was the SIAC coach of the year in both 2022 and 2023. In 2021, the SIAC coach of the year was Gabe Giardina (then of Albany State), who was on the opposing sideline last week as Charleston Southern’s head coach.

The weather forecast for Saturday in Charleston: not great. Showers and thunderstorms are likely before, during, and after the game. The chance of precipitation is 60%.

I guess that is the tradeoff for the lack of furnace-like conditions for a noon kickoff. (The projected high on Saturday is only 79 degrees.)

Saturday’s game is being called a “whiteout”. Fans are encouraged to wear white apparel (presumably including rain ponchos). The team, however, will not wear white jerseys, because the visiting team has the right to nix that, and S.C. State elected to exercise its veto.

I would expect the The Citadel to wear its light blue jerseys, and for SCSU to showcase its white tops.

Per the game notes, there are apparently no changes to The Citadel’s depth chart from Game 1 to Game 2.

The home opener will double as Hall of Fame Weekend at The Citadel. The banquet is on Friday night, and the honorees are a particularly impressive group. I would anticipate a lot of people will be in town this weekend for the festivities, and that will include a larger-than-normal cohort of football alums.

It is also a big weekend for South Carolina State’s alumni chapter in Charleston, which has organized a tailgate on Saturday that will undoubtedly be humming with activity.

In other words, the scene should be a busy one. It should be fun (and wet). Get there early.

2024 Football: The Citadel wins its season opener! Hallelujah!

I have basically semi-retired this blog, but I decided to throw in a few stats and comments after last night’s victory. This won’t be a regular thing, but it’s a long weekend and I had a few minutes, so…

Advanced stats of note from The Citadel’s 22-21 victory over Charleston Southern in North Charleston:

  The Citadel Charleston Southern
Starting Field Position Average 32.78 21.78
Success Rate (offense) 47.8% 50.0%
Big plays (20+ yards) 4 6
Finishing drives (average points once inside 40) 3.67 4.67
Turnovers 1 1
Expected turnovers 1.72 1.44
Possessions 9 9
Points per possession 2.44 2.33
Offensive Plays 65 54
Yards/rush (sack-adjusted) 4.11 4.39
Yards/pass attempt (sack-adjusted) 9.33 9.46
Yards/play 5.55 7.02
3rd down conversions 53.8% (7-13) 40.0% (4-10)
4th down conversions 1 for 1 2 for 2
Red Zone TD% 75.0% 100.0%
Net punting 41.67 38.33
Time of possession 32:11 27:49
TOP/offensive play 29.26 seconds 29.28 seconds
Penalties 4 for 32 yards 4 for 25 yards
1st down passing 4/5 (67 yards) 10/12, two sacks (198 net yards)
3rd and long passing 1/4, one sack (22 net yards) 1/1, one sack (0 net yards)
4th down passing 0/0 2/2 (30 yards)
1st down yards/play 6.03 10.00
3rd down average yards to go 6.0 7.1
Defensive 3-and-outs+ 2 (of 9) 1 (of 9)

Apologies for the formatting. WordPress is not ideal for that sort of thing, or perhaps any sort of thing…

Some notes on the above:

  • These statistics do not include the final drive of the first half for Charleston Southern (three plays, ending in a kneel-down) and the final drive of the second half for The Citadel (one play, a kneel-down).
  • The ‘Finishing Drives’ category does not include Charleston Southern’s final possession of the second half (which I decided fell under “desperation mode”).
  • Trying to compile “advanced” statistics has become more difficult thanks to the SoCon changing its statistical formatting. It is now considerably worse. (Actually, the league website as a whole is considerably worse than it was, thanks to a recent update.)
  • The play-by-play for the game was fairly clean — not bad for a first game of the season. I did spot a discrepancy, which was part of a sequence midway through the second quarter. I’ve corrected a yardage error which involved a sack, but I believe there was another yardage mistake on a prior play. (It was only 2 yards, though, and didn’t really affect the averages, so let’s not tell anyone else about it.)
  • The Citadel won the starting field position battle, which was a key to the game. Even if you take out the fumble exchange in the fourth quarter, the Bulldogs would have had an edge of over five yards in starting field position. Even in a game with limited possessions, that adds up.
  • Yes, Charleston Southern averaged exactly 10 yards per play on first down, mostly due to several big plays in the passing game. The Bulldogs’ defense definitely needs to improve in that area.
  • The Citadel might want to throw the ball on first down a little more often itself. The Bulldogs were very effective doing so in limited attempts.

Miscellaneous observations:

– I thought the Bulldogs were the stronger, more well-conditioned team as the game progressed, a major reason The Citadel was able to come back from an 18-point second-half deficit to win. That is a credit to the work done in the offseason. 

– The offensive play-calling for The Citadel seemed to be more dynamic in the second half. Part of that can be attributed to trailing by multiple scores, to be sure, but I also thought there was an increase in confidence in the offense’s execution as the night wore on. I hope that assurance continues throughout the season.

– Not included in the advanced stats: the field goal story, which obviously went The Citadel’s way. The Bulldogs got a much-needed three points at the end of the first half, and the Buccaneers’ two attempts both went awry (the first being deflected, and the second altered if not tipped by an onrushing defender).

The special teams advantage for The Citadel was critical.

– A lot of times, you will see a team try for a big play on offense (often involving some trickery) after forcing a turnover — a quick strike while the iron is hot, taking advantage of momentum and the other team’s defense possibly not being ready for action after the sudden possession change.

That said, I’m not sure it was a great idea for Charleston Southern to call a relatively slow-developing play-action pass after recovering a fumble, particularly inside its own 25 with less than five minutes to play and nursing a six-point lead.

That decision didn’t work out, to say the least.

– According to the online participation report, The Citadel had 58 players see action on Saturday night. Five of them were “true” freshmen — Lee Alexander Jr., Caleb Davis, Will Hall, Braylon Knauth, and Nikolas Mirabella. Five redshirt freshmen also played, as did eight “true” sophomores.

Charleston Southern had 46 players see the field.

One note of caution: the online participation report is not always 100% accurate.

– Twelve players who started for the Bulldogs in last season’s final game at East Tennessee State also started against Charleston Southern — seven on offense (including four of the offensive linemen), and five on defense. The Citadel debuted a new placekicker and long snapper, while returning its punter and holder.

Next week: South Carolina State, noon ET, Johnson Hagood Stadium. That should be a hot ticket, figuratively and literally.

The Citadel is undefeated. That sounds good, doesn’t it?