The Citadel vs. VMI, to be played on Alumni Memorial Field at Foster Stadium in Lexington, Virginia, with kickoff at 1:30 pm ET on Saturday, November 12. The game will not be televised.
The contest will be streamed on ESPN3.com, with Wade Branner providing play-by-play and Dave Harding supplying the analysis.
Mike Legg (the “Voice of the Bulldogs”) will call the action alongside analyst Lee Glaze.
It is also possible to listen to the action with a smartphone, using a TuneIn Radio application.
Links of interest:
– Brent Thompson’s 11/8 press conference, including comments from Cody Clark and Tyler Renew (video)
– Brent Thompson’s 11/9 radio show (video)
The second week of preliminary rankings by the FCS selection committee resulted in a few changes, but by and large those adjustments did not really affect The Citadel.
|Week 2 Rank||School||Previous (Week 1)|
|3||North Dakota State||4|
|5||Sam Houston State||2|
The biggest news was Sam Houston State dropping from #2 to #5. The Bearkats are one of two undefeated FCS teams, with The Citadel being the other. However, SHSU’s strength of schedule is weak when compared to all but one of the other top eight teams (we’ll get to the exception in a moment).
Last week, North Dakota State fans (and media members) complained vociferously after Sam Houston State was ranked ahead of the Bison. They had a point.
It is impossible to know whether or not certain members of the selection committee were influenced by the noise emanating from Fargo. I could make a good guess, though.
Of course, NDSU didn’t get everything it wanted. North Dakota State is still ranked behind Eastern Washington and Jacksonville State. The latter school’s #1 ranking continues to be a bit puzzling.
Schedule strength of the top 10 teams through last week’s games (incidentally, Samford is 2nd overall in this category):
- Jacksonville State (schedule strength of 101st out of 124 FCS teams)
- Eastern Washington (tied for 12th)
- North Dakota State (3rd)
- James Madison (35th)
- Sam Houston State (89th)
- The Citadel (tied for 12th)
- Chattanooga (34th)
- Richmond (37th)
- Central Arkansas (82nd)
- North Dakota (38th)
Jacksonville State is 8-1. The one defeat came at LSU, so nobody is saying that JSU should be penalized severely for its loss. However, the Gamecocks don’t play in a very strong league, and don’t have the non-conference schedule heft to match that of Eastern Washington and North Dakota State — and both of those schools also play in tougher conferences while maintaining identical 8-1 records.
Of course, some observers would note that one difference between the three schools is that Jacksonville State’s director of athletics is on the selection committee.
The Citadel is undefeated, has a significantly better strength of schedule, and also has a win over another team in the top 10 of the rankings. However, not only are the Bulldogs behind Jacksonville State, they are ranked below Sam Houston State as well. There is no legitimate reason for that to be the case.
In my opinion, The Citadel should currently be ranked in the top 4. Eastern Washington and North Dakota State should be 1-2 in some order, followed by James Madison and The Citadel in the 3-4 spots. However, unless JSU and SHSU lose, the Bulldogs are not likely to pass either one of them (particularly Jacksonville State).
This effectively means The Citadel’s seeding “ceiling” is probably #5. The difference between being seeded #5 instead of #4 could be the difference between playing at home or on the road in a potential quarterfinal game.
That would be unfortunate for The Citadel.
Earlier this week, SB Nation’s “Football Study Hall” site posted a report on tempo at the FBS level. It’s a very interesting and well-considered piece.
After I read it, I decided to take a look at pace of play in FCS. Basically, I took stats from 122 teams (for practical reasons, I didn’t include “transitional” schools Abilene Christian and Incarnate Word), and determined how quickly FCS teams have run offensive plays so far in 2016. Here are the top 20 squads:
|Team (Conference)||Time between plays (seconds)|
|Stephen F. Austin (Southland)||19.49872|
|Eastern Kentucky (OVC)||19.68576|
|South Dakota (MVFC)||20.86083|
|Sam Houston State (Southland)||21.5656|
|Murray State (OVC)||21.80123|
|Eastern Washington (Big Sky)||22.09565|
|Southern Utah (Big Sky)||22.11938|
|Southern Illinois (MVFC)||22.12278|
|Indiana State (MVFC)||22.34259|
|Dartmouth (Ivy League)||22.52891|
|Western Carolina (Southern)||22.53821|
|Eastern Illinois (OVC)||22.7168|
|Sacramento State (Big Sky)||22.78134|
|Morehead State (Pioneer)||23.02286|
|Montana (Big Sky)||23.18182|
|Princeton (Ivy League)||23.31231|
|Columbia (Ivy League)||23.37113|
Stephen F. Austin’s pace is faster than all but three teams in FBS: Missouri (which is absurdly fast), Baylor, and California.
These are the 20 “slowest” teams, with Wofford taking more time between plays than any other team in FCS (only Stanford and Georgia Tech are slower at the FBS level):
|Team (conference)||Time between plays (seconds)|
|Florida A&M (Mid-Eastern)||28.66306|
|Youngstown State (MVFC)||28.76508|
|Mississippi Valley St. (Southwestern)||28.88979|
|Robert Morris (Northeast)||29.07609|
|North Dakota (Big Sky)||29.10984|
|Presbyterian (Big South)||29.31664|
|San Diego (Pioneer)||29.42857|
|Albany (NY) (Colonial)||29.43738|
|Stony Brook (Colonial)||29.46168|
|Tennessee Tech (OVC)||29.77833|
|Texas Southern (Southwestern)||30.02473|
|Tennessee State (OVC)||30.05179|
|Charleston Southern (Big South)||30.076|
|North Dakota State (MVFC)||30.33216|
|Saint Francis (PA) (Northeast)||30.35612|
In my FCS Playoffs primer, I mentioned this comment from the chairman of the selection committee, Brian Hutchinson, when asked by an interviewer about “Sam Houston State’s value to the committee”:
The value of Sam Houston State is that they are an 8-0 team right now [that] is averaging close to 60 points per game and close to 600 yards of [total] offense. That’s the value that people see.
As I said in that post, I hope no committee members will actually use total offense as a criterion of any real significance. Part of my concern has to do with schedule strength, of course, but style of play is also a factor.
Sam Houston State leads FCS in total offense. As you can see above, SHSU is also the 5th-fastest offense in the division, in terms of pace of play.
I think it would be more than a little ridiculous to use total offense as a marker for comparing the Bearkats to teams like Chattanooga (19th in total offense, but the 9th “slowest” team) or The Citadel (23rd in total offense, and in the bottom third in pace of play, at 27.33 seconds between plays). The latter two teams shouldn’t have their style of play held against them by a committee member who is overly impressed by raw statistics.
While I’ve got this information handy, here are pace of play rankings for the nine SoCon squads, plus a few other teams:
- Stephen F. Austin (1st out of 122)
- Samford (3rd)
- Sam Houston State (5th)
- Eastern Washington (7th)
- Western Carolina (12th)
- VMI (20th)
- Mercer (27th)
- James Madison (37th)
- Lehigh (41st)
- Harvard (44th)
- Liberty (47th)
- Kennesaw State (71st)
- The Citadel (84th)
- Gardner-Webb (87th)
- East Tennessee State (91st)
- Furman (95th)
- Presbyterian (110th)
- Chattanooga (114th)
- Charleston Southern (118th)
- North Dakota State (119th)
- St. Francis [PA] (120th)
- Delaware (121st)
- Wofford (122nd)
Friday is Founders Day at VMI:
The VMI Corps of Cadets will commemorate Founders Day this Friday with a parade featuring a 17-gun salute executed by the Cadet Battery to honor VMI’s founders and the nation’s veterans.
The anniversary, which marks 177 years since 23 VMI cadets relieved the state militia and converted the state arsenal into the Institute, will also see the dedication of the recently renovated Cormack and Cocke halls at 10 and 11 a.m., respectively.
There will also be a parade at 10:30 am on Saturday.
If you’re going to the game, be sure you’re up to speed on the parking situation.
Scott Wachenheim is in his second year as VMI’s head coach. His team is 3-6 this season, 1-5 in SoCon play. That qualifies as improvement for the Keydets’ football program, given that VMI had won two games in each of the last five years.
The Keydets opened the 2016 season by dropping a 47-24 decision at Akron. VMI’s defense allowed 576 yards of total offense, but the Keydets stayed in the game, putting together two drives of 90+ yards to pull within two points as the third quarter ended.
Akron scored 21 fourth-quarter points to ice the contest. However, it was a very respectable showing by VMI against an FBS opponent.
VMI’s next game was a 17-13 victory at Morehead State. While the Keydets’ loss to Akron was encouraging, the win over the Eagles (which play football in the non-scholarship Pioneer League) was not. VMI’s offense was sluggish, but the defense kept Morehead State at bay, allowing the fewest points to a Keydets opponent in four seasons.
A third straight road game resulted in a triple overtime victory, 23-17 over Bucknell. The Keydets did not give up any points in the three OT sessions.
It was the first time VMI had won back-to-back games since 2005, and (unbelievably) the first time the program had won consecutive road games since the last game of the 1981 season and the first game of the 1982 campaign.
Back in Lexington, another overtime affair did not go the Keydets’ way. Mercer edged VMI 33-30 in a game reportedly marred by poor SoCon officiating (very surprising, I know). VMI trailed 21-7 at halftime before making a comeback, taking the lead with just 32 seconds remaining in regulation. The Keydets could not hold the lead, and then lost in OT.
VMI rebounded from that setback with a 37-7 home victory over East Tennessee State. Al Cobb threw three TD passes, and the Keydets rushed for 233 yards.
Since that game, VMI has lost four straight contests. The first of those defeats was a 55-21 loss at Samford. SU quarterback Devlin Hodges threw for 435 yards and 5 TDs, and VMI also got victimized by a pick-6.
Chattanooga then beat the Keydets 30-13. UTC rushed for 297 yards despite Derrick Craine missing the game with an injury. One of VMI’s two TDs was a 79-yard bomb from Al Cobb to Javeon Lara.
VMI returned home, but was beaten in Lexington 24-10 by Furman. The loss was a costly one for the Keydets, as Cobb suffered a shoulder injury.
Last week, VMI lost 32-29 at Western Carolina. The Keydets should have won the game, but basically handed the victory to the Catamounts with a series of miscues. Among other things:
- VMI fumbled the opening kickoff, which was returned by WCU for a touchdown
- The Keydets had four kicks blocked (two field goal attempts, two PATs)
- VMI threw three interceptions
- Western Carolina scored with 54 seconds to play on a 53-yard pass
Statistics of note for VMI:
|Net punt average||34.6||34.3|
|Time of poss/game||28:50||31:10|
|3rd-down conv %||32.9%||34.8%|
|Red Zone TD%||(22-35) 63%||(23-36) 64%|
- VMI is 2nd nationally in fewest penalties per game
- The Keydets are 84th in FCS in scoring defense and 63rd in rushing defense
- VMI is 29th in defensive third down conversion rate
- The Keydets are 85th in time of possession
- VMI is 28th in passing offense
Statistics of consequence for The Citadel:
|Net punt average||37.3||36.6|
|Time of poss/game||34:37:00||25:22:00|
|3rd-down conv %||49.7%||31.8%|
|Red Zone TD%||(22-39) 56%||(12-20) 60%|
- The Citadel leads the nation in rushing offense (374.0 yards/game) and is seventh in average yards/rush
- The Bulldogs are 9th in offensive third down conversion rate
- The Citadel is third nationally in time of possession
- The Bulldogs are 13th in fewest penalties per game
- The Citadel is 21st in the country in turnover margin
- The Bulldogs are 15th nationally in defensive third down conversion rate
VMI throws the ball on 49.8% of its offensive plays from scrimmage, with 68.2% of the Keydets’ total yards coming via the air. The Keydets operate out of the spread.
Al Cobb was the preseason choice as the SoCon’s all-conference quarterback. Cobb was injured against Furman and did not play last week versus Western Carolina.
Will he play on Saturday? Cobb is not listed on the two-deep. According to an article in The Roanoke Times, he may be available.
The starter, though, will be redshirt freshman Austin Coulling (6’4″, 200 lbs.). Coulling, a native of Salem, Virginia, has played in five games this season, starting against WCU last Saturday.
For the season, he is completing 56.9% of his passes, averaging 7.5 yards per attempt, with two touchdown passes and six interceptions.
Coulling does not lack for confidence:
After hours of watching video, Coulling said he thinks there are some areas in The Citadel defense that the offense can exploit.
“There are opportunities there for us to take,” Coulling said. “As a team, if we come out with the same energy we came out with last week and execute more efficiently than we did last week and have the same running game as we had last week, I mean, anything can happen. … We can come out on top.”
Daz Palmer (5’10”, 175 lbs.) is a freshman from Norfolk who is leading the Keydets in rushing. He is averaging 4.5 yards per carry, with 3 rushing TDs. Palmer also has 12 receptions this season.
Wide receiver Aaron Sanders (6’2″, 190 lbs.) was a preseason all-league pick. He has 62 receptions so far this year, with two TDs. Sanders had 7 catches last year versus The Citadel; in fact, Sanders has had 7 receptions in each of his last two games against the Bulldogs (including a 165-yard receiving performance in 2014).
Fellow wideout Dane Forlines (5’10”, 190 lbs.) made the all-conference team last year as a return specialist. Forlines is a dangerous punt returner, averaging 12.9 yards last season and 9.3 yards this year in that discipline. He is second on the team in receptions, with 47 catches and one TD.
Starting tight end Ryan Swingle (6’3″, 232 lbs.) has 30 receptions and four touchdown catches this season. The former quarterback is also the holder on placekicks, and VMI is not afraid to take advantage of his versatility. He threw a 50-yard pass on a trick play against Mercer.
VMI’s projected starting offensive line averages 6’3″, 279 lbs. According to the two-deep, the offensive tackles will be flipped for the game against The Citadel.
Fifth-year senior Iyan Roseborough (6’3″, 335 lbs.) has played right tackle this season for the Keydets, but is listed as the left tackle on this week’s depth chart. Roseborough is a native of Jenkinsville, South Carolina, and graduated from Fairfield Central High School.
Redshirt freshman Cole Brummit (6’4″, 250 lbs.) made his first career start against Western Carolina at left tackle. He is listed as the right tackle this week.
VMI’s defense normally lines up in a 3-4. In last season’s contest, the Keydets were generally effective at bottling up The Citadel’s triple option attack. After Cam Jackson broke loose for a 68-yard TD on the Bulldogs’ fourth play from scrimmage, VMI did not allow another offensive TD.
The Keydets’ D is led by two active inside linebackers. Ryan Francis (6’1″, 205 lbs.) is a redshirt junior from Knoxville who had 15 tackles versus The Citadel in last year’s matchup. Allan Cratsenberg (6’3″, 220 lbs.) is a junior from Natrona, Pennsylvania; he had 11 stops against the Bulldogs in last season’s game.
The two are currently tied for the team lead in tackles, with 94 each. They have combined for 21 tackles for loss, including eight sacks.
Francis is the main pass rusher, with six of those sacks; he also has two fumble recoveries. Against Mercer, Francis also threw a pass out of a fake punt formation; it was intercepted.
Another linebacker, Alijah Robinson (6’0″, 205 lbs.) is third on the team in tackes, with 58. Robinson also has two sacks.
Cornerback Riuq Trotman (5’9″ 155 lbs.) is a sophomore from Virginia Beach who leads the Keydets in interceptions, with three.
Dillon Christopher (6’2″, 200 lbs.) is in his fourth year as a placekicker for the Keydets. He has shared kicking duties with freshman Reed King (5’9″, 150 lbs.).
Regardless of the kicker, VMI has had major problems in the kicking game this season, with nine blocked kicks — five field goal attempts, and four PAT tries.
Christopher does have a strong leg, which he employs on kickoffs.
VMI’s punter is redshirt sophomore Bill Hogan (6’1″, 225 lbs.), who can also play linebacker. He has had one punt blocked this season. Hogan was the punter for VMI when the Keydets played The Citadel last season, and did a solid job.
Jake Keith (5’10”, 190 lbs.), a freshman from Blacksburg, is the long snapper.
Odds and ends:
– The weather forecast for Saturday in Lexington, Virginia, per the National Weather Service: sunny, with a high of 52 degrees. The projected low on Saturday night is 27 degrees.
– Per one source that deals in such matters, The Citadel is an 18-point favorite over VMI, with an over/under of 47.5.
– Other lines involving SoCon teams: Chattanooga is a 7.5-point favorite over Wofford; Samford is a 15.5-point favorite against Mercer; Furman is a 6.5-point favorite over Western Carolina; and East Tennessee State is a 24-point favorite against Cumberland.
Gardner-Webb (now 4-6) is off this week, presumably celebrating its stunning victory at Charleston Southern last Saturday. North Carolina (7-3) was upset by Duke 28-27 on Thursday night.
– Massey Ratings: The Citadel is ranked 4th in FCS (moving up one spot from last week, the second consecutive week the Bulldogs have crept up one position). VMI is ranked 69th.
Massey projects The Citadel to have a 93% chance of winning, with a predicted final score of The Citadel 34, VMI 13.
Other FCS rankings in Massey of note: Chattanooga (8th), Samford (12th), Wofford (19th), Mercer (41st), Gardner-Webb (46th), Furman (47th), Western Carolina (64th), East Tennessee State (82nd).
The top ten in Massey’s rankings, in order: North Dakota State, Eastern Washington, Jacksonville State, The Citadel, Central Arkansas, South Dakota State, Youngstown State, Chattanooga, Sam Houston State, and Northern Iowa.
– VMI’s game notes roster includes 69 natives of Virginia. Other states represented on the squad: Tennessee (9), North Carolina (4), Pennsylvania (4), Georgia (3), Alabama (2), and one each from West Virginia, Louisiana, New York, Michigan, Texas, Maryland, and South Carolina.
– The Citadel’s geographic roster breakdown (per the school’s website) is as follows: South Carolina (47 players), Georgia (23), Florida (9), North Carolina (7), Alabama (4), Pennsylvania (4), Texas (4), and one each from Louisiana, Maryland, Kansas, Oklahoma, Nevada, and West Virginia.
– VMI concludes its season next week at Wofford.
– FBS opponents for VMI in future seasons include Toledo and Old Dominion in 2018; Army in 2019; and North Carolina State in 2023.
– On The Citadel’s two-deep this week, Evan McField is listed as the #2 B-back, with Isiaha Smith not listed on the depth chart. That is the only change from last week’s two-deep.
– Game notes factoid of the week: The Citadel has rushed for at least 400 yards in five games this season, tying the school’s single-season record. Those five games: North Greenville (559 yards, the most by an FCS school in a game so far in 2016), Western Carolina (513), Samford (463), East Tennessee State (427), and Gardner-Webb (419).
– With its victory over Samford on Saturday, The Citadel won its fifth consecutive Homecoming game. The Bulldogs won their fifth straight Parents’ Day game earlier in the season when they defeated Chattanooga.
The ten consecutive “celebration” victories are a modern-day school record. The Citadel had never won eight straight such games prior to the current run.
– The original cost of the Silver Shako (which was created in 1976) was $532.72.
– More than 40 players (and a few coaches) from VMI’s 1981 team will be honored at halftime of Saturday’s game. That Keydets squad beat Army and Virginia Tech, finishing with a 6-3-1 record. VMI has not had a winning season since that year.
On his radio show, Brent Thompson was asked about resting starters, trying to avoid injuries, etc., given that The Citadel has clinched a playoff spot. Thompson’s response:
It’s a loser’s mentality, there’s no doubt about that. You don’t go out there worrying about which guys are going to get hurt and who’s going to do this, and who’s going to do that. We’re going to go out there and play the game, and play the game to win. There’s a game on our schedule, it’s assigned to us, and we’re going to…go out there and give it our best. It doesn’t really matter who it is, whether it’s this week or next week…we’re going to try to play it, and try to play it to win it. If there are injuries…that’s part of the game and we can’t concern ourselves with that.
Thompson also noted that the offense did not play well against VMI last season, and wants to see improvement this year.
The coach also mentioned the importance of getting a bye for the FCS playoffs. If the Bulldogs want to seriously contend for the national title, they almost certainly need to be a seeded team, and receive the bye that goes with that designation.
A loss to VMI would almost certainly end The Citadel’s chance at a bye. Conversely, the game against North Carolina in two weeks will probably not be a factor in The Citadel’s postseason placement, unless the Bulldogs perform well in that contest.
The Citadel has been a member of the Southern Conference since 1936. In all that time, the football team has never finished undefeated in league play.
Along with the outright SoCon title, and a tenth straight victory, the opportunity to finish undefeated in the conference would be reason enough for the Bulldogs to want this game very badly. They don’t really need another reason, however.
This is the Military Classic of the South.
It will be a fierce contest. VMI will come ready to play on Saturday. The Citadel must respond in kind, and with even greater ferocity.
The coveted Silver Shako is at stake, the greatest trophy in all of sports.
The Bulldogs have to do whatever it takes to keep it, and bring it back to Charleston, where it belongs.
Filed under: Football, The Citadel | Tagged: Brent Thompson, Cam Jackson, Chattanooga, FCS playoffs, Jacksonville State, James Madison, North Dakota State, Sam Houston State, Samford, SoCon, The Citadel, VMI |